As Ned Stark once said: "Everything before 'but' is horse shit". While there were moments we wanted to enjoy, we have to be honest: this episode felt like a fundamental disconnect from the characters and the stakes we know.
We don't take pleasure in tearing this episode apart, but we couldn't just pretend otherwise. We went in with high hopes, but we were met with a conceptual approach that, in our view, failed to land. From logistical plot holes that defy the show's own internal rules to character beats that ignored the established emotional continuity, we break down why this installment didn't work for us.
This isn't a critique of a declining series—last week's episode earned a 9.5 from us—but this specific episode was a misfire that we simply can't defend. We’re pulling back the curtain on why the logic fell apart and why, for the first time, we found ourselves struggling to find the ground to stand on.
If you’ve finished the episode and found yourself scratching your head at the decision-making, this is the deep dive you’ve been waiting for. We’re discussing the "fake Daeron" plot, the questionable Corlys scene, and why this conceptual swing felt like such a massive waste of screen time.